Robust Evidence and Argument Have Currency
Created by on 6/27/2016 8:47:27 PM

Robust Evidence and Argument Have Currency Today

Screen Shot 2015-01-27 at 1.10.37 AM


There is a strong heritage of evidence and good argument, a multivalent discourse, to establish the credibility and viability of the Christian faith. It is a several stranded cord which represents centuries of work, research, and debate by scholars. There is a strong rational and empirical ground or space to discuss all the parameters of the Christian convictions and spiritual journey. It offers a rich array of evidence for the seeker and the interested skeptic or agnostic.

  1. Meaningful Religious Experience: This refers to the power of individual stories with God, divine encounters and personal transformation. Where has God met me in my human situation and pain? How has my faith made an impact on my life? Stories of other saints who incarnate love or radical pursuit of God (Mother Teresa, Jean Vanier, Francis of Assissi, Martin Luther). David Adams Richards a famous Canadian novelist has such evidence: God Is: my search for faith in a secular world. (bestseller). Two billion plus believers is quite a number to deceive from all walks of life, all cultures, all careers, and all levels of education and wealth.
  1. Philosophical Credibility Tests These include criteria of coherence, consistency, unity, comprehensiveness (more important in the early modern outlook or those oriented to Anglo-American philosophy and the laws of logic). What is the explanatory range and cogency of  the Christian worldview? How much of reality can it explain? Is it compatible or does it conflict with science and how so?  Natural theology uses the wonders of nature to point to a creative mind, a cosmic artist; human consciousness and moral bent to point to a cosmic mind or a moral ground of the good (e.g. Robert J. Spitzer, New Proofs for the Existence of God: contributions of contemporary physics and philosophy; Faith and Reason: Three Views. edited by Steve Wilkins; David Bentley Hart, The Experience of God: being consciousness. bliss). Critical realism is a key term; it encourages critical thinking and an open mind.
  1. Historical Evidence or Verification Who was Jesus? Can we believe in his resurrection? What about the scholarship behind the Scriptural documents? What evidence do we have from archaeology of the Ancient Near East? (See Rodney Stark, One True God: Historical Consequences of Monotheism. He is a major contributor in research on Christianity’s social impact. See also David Bentley Hart Atheist Delusions: the Christian revolution and its fashionable enemies.) See also the new Christianity on Trial: a lawyer examines the Christian faith by W. Mark Lanier (IVP 2014). This tends towards the empirical test or the integrity of the Christian story.
  1. Practical/Pragmatic Test or Livability We might say to our friend, “That’s a clever idea of reality that makes you God, but can you live it out responsibly without hurting a lot of people?” It is one thing to think nihilistically, another to live it to its bitter end. Reality bites back: this is important for university students who love those all-night residence discussions. One can invent sophisticated views of the universe, but can we build any long-term relationship upon it? You may like the idea of a world without God and without morality, but you may also be the first to cry injustice if you or your family are violated in some way. One cannot have the proverbial cake and eat it as well.
  1. Special Revelation This includes the prophetic and apostolic records in Old and New Testaments. This is a really astounding set of records with millions of hours of top scholarship behind it. Bishop Lesslie Newbigin in Gospel in a Pluralistic Society says we need to inhabit or indwell the biblical story, be embedded and nourished by it thoroughly. Natural revelation in creation is not enough; otherwise Christian ethics would be full of violence and cannibalism, tooth and claw; we need natural and special revelation in balance (Alister McGrath, A Fine-tuned Universe: the quest for God in science and theology) What is the Creator like and what does he have for us, expect of us? What is the storyline, the human narrative of the Bible? Is there meaning beyond mere survival, beyond mere human flourishing? The human narrative is powerfully recast in the Bible; it suggests that we are hard-wired for community and benevolence.
  1. Love, Compassion & Community People need to witness the human good incarnated in Christian believers, a good which is sourced in the infinite goodness of God. Incarnational humanism can be impressive: (Jens Zimmerman, Incarantional Humanism; D. Stephen Long, The Goodness of God)). One's apologetic has to include words and argument, but also more than words--integrity, hope, compassion. James Davison Hunter in To Change the World articulates a very powerful idea of faithful presence, a commitment to shalom, the well-being or human flourishing of others. Jim Wallis has a new book along this line which includes compassion and the transformation of society in the gospel of Jesus: The (Un)Common Good. “People need both reasons of the heart and reasons of the mind: credibility and relevance.” writes scientist and theologian Blaise Pascal.

Our Experience Establishes this Conviction: Intellectual Credibility/Cogency + Personal Relevance + Demonstrable Moral Integrity --> promotes Serious Plausibility and Curiosity in the Mind of the Seeker. Click on the Apologetics Resources button on GCU Blog to get a taste of some excellent writing in this area and answers to your questions.

This multifaceted approach builds bridges and can rebuild the plausibility conditions for Christian faith in our late modern culture, in order to help people escape from Nihilism (a failure of culture). This is a trajectory of intrigue, attraction and engagement and hopefully down the road a life of faithful discipleship, meaning and joy. Willingness to deal with doubts and skepticism is vital. We are all some admixture or  combination of faith and doubt; it is a question of how we sort through both our faith and our doubt as a journey to maturity: See Philip Yancey, Reaching for the Invisible God. At the end of the day, we all have to make sense of our world and our experience. We can ill afford to keep our head in the sand and hope the issues will disappear.

~Gord Carkner

More Discipling Rescources
Nov25 Mary's Epiphany of Transcendence
Published: Nov 25 2015


Epiphanies come in various forms, a great work of art, a full moon, or a beautiful sunset. But there can also be epiphanies of the heart that resonate deep wit...
Read More..
Jul21 Twin Heritages: Christ and University
Published: Jul 21 2015


Two Heritages: Christ and University a. What if we could harness the power, resources and critical skills of the research university for the growth and ...
Read More..
Jul14 Christ of the Indian Road
Published: Jul 14 2015


E. Stanley Jones.  Christ Of The Indian Road . New York: Abingdon Press, 1925. I don’t usually read a lot of books that are 90 years old, but this one w...
Read More..
Jul08 Boundless: What Global Expressions Of Faith Teach Us About Following Jesus
Published: Jul 08 2015


Bishop, Bryan. Boundless: What Global Expressions of Faith Teach Us About Following Jesus. Grand Rapids: Baker Books, 2015. Reviewed by Craig Kraft W...
Read More..
Jul08 How To Love Your Neighbor Without Being Weird – Amy Lively
Published: Jul 08 2015


Lively, Amy. How To Love Your Neighbor Without Being Weird . Minneapolis: Bethany House, 2015 Reviewed by Craig Kraft Lively has taken the Lord’s comma...
Read More..
Feb26 Dialogue on Jesus
Published: Feb 26 2015


There exist today in the minds of people many different versions of Jesus. Cultural interpretation is a key factor in this dialogue. Few would dispute that Je...
Read More..
Feb14 Dialogue in Language of the Good
Published: Feb 14 2015


How can we talk about morality these days in a civil, rational manner? Opinions can be strong and emotions can be close to the surface. Discussions can be qui...
Read More..
Feb12 Dialogue on Worldviews
Published: Feb 12 2015


The ability to think, dialogue and examine arguments and evidence within the context of worldview gives a tremendous edge, latitude and creativity to any disc...
Read More..
Feb08 Robust Evidence and Argument Have Currency
Published: Feb 08 2015


There is a strong heritage of evidence and good argument, a multivalent discourse, to establish the credibility and viability of the Christian faith. It is a ...
Read More..
Feb06 Building Bridges to Faith
Published: Feb 06 2015


Building Bridges : This is the beginning of a series on stimulating dialogue with friends and clleagues. It is clear that we need fresh approaches to asking s...
Read More..
Digging Deeper Workshop Digging Deeper Workshop
Published: Jan 13 2015


David Collins developed the Digging Deeper workshop to allow people to explore what it means to be a disciple of Jesus Christ. Are you content with who you ...
Read More..
Nov15 Mapping the Arenas of Discipleship in the 21st Century
Published: Nov 15 2014


This is part of the Discipleship Project within Outreach Canada, a think tank on future possibilities and opportunities within Canada. In this article, I try t...
Read More..
Oct21 Jesus is the Yes and Amen
Published: Oct 21 2014


In II Corinthians 1, the Apostle Paul writes that Jesus is the  Yes  and the  Amen  to it all. What does this mean? Below are some reflections from our UBC Gr...
Read More..
Jul30 The Power of One on One – Jim Stump
Published: Jul 30 2014


Jim Stump. The Power of One on One . 2014. Reviewed by Craig Kraft Jim Stump says that he won the job lottery when he became a full time mentor to college...
Read More..
Jul19 Nihilism and the Incarnation
Published: Jul 19 2014


This article is the concluding section of a 70 page article on Recovery from the Slumber of Nihilism. it draws heavily on the brilliant insights of Canada's pr...
Read More..