CAMPUS MINISTRY

Is there Rational Evidence for the Resurrection?

Gordon Carkner / Monday, April 11, 2022

Under Investigation: Some Allege that the Resurrection of Jesus was a Hoax

If this statement is true, there is no evidence for the most central Christian belief next to the existence of God. That would be tragic indeed. As the Apostle Paul wrote to one of the first Christian churches, “If Christ has not been raised, our preaching is useless, and so is your faith” (1 Corinthians 15:14). Easter becomes pure myth without historical substance. This is a powder keg question.

But a reasonable and responsible person needs solid evidence. It is common historical knowledge that Jesus died on a Roman cross and was buried. And the biblical records indicate both that his tomb was found empty shortly afterwards and that a large number of people claimed to have spoken, walked and eaten with him after his death. These claims are indeed unusual, even startling! They need explanation. We must decide whether there is a more plausible alternative than an actual physical, bodily resurrection. Much hangs on the answer.

Alternate Explanations

Alternate explanations abound:

  1. that thieves stole the body of Jesus;
  2. that the Roman or Jewish authorities stole it;
  3. that Jesus’ disciples stole it; and 
  4. that Jesus was not actually dead when buried and left the tomb on his own. 

Below we deal with each one briefly.

1. That Theives Stole the Body of Jesus

We are told (for example in Matthew chapter 27:62 through to chapter 28:4) that the authorities placed a guard at the tomb to prevent the body from being stolen. 

And when the body was discovered to be missing, it was noted that the grave clothes—loaded with spices to preserve the body—were still present. They would be strange grave robbers who would fight Roman soldiers to steal a naked corpse, when the only thing of value in the tomb would have been the spice-laden grave clothes.

2. That Roman or Jewish Authorities Stole the Body of Jesus

The authorities posted the guard to keep the body buried. We must ask why they would subsequently remove it.

When Christianity was first proclaimed, it was seen as a threat to the political and religious establishment of the day. Jesus was executed partly as a threat to Rome’s sovereignty. Because the new teaching was explicitly based upon belief in the resurrection, it would have been a simple matter for the authorities to quash the rumour by producing the body of Jesus. The fact that they did not do so indicates that they did not have the body. Why hold back such critical evidence?

3. That Jesus’ Disciples Stole the Body of Jesus

Because Roman discipline provided punishments ranging from beatings to death for sleeping on duty, we may assume that the soldiers were alert. This means that the disciples (a discouraged, frightened group of fishermen, tax collectors. and one political activist) would have had to fight the soldiers to get the body—a fight they stood a poor chance of winning.

But it was not just the disciples who claimed to have seen Jesus alive post-crucifixion. They would, in other words, have had to convince others to join them in their deception—a deception these others would have no motive for maintaining.

Furthermore, 11 out of the original 12 disciples were martyred for their belief and their claims that Jesus rose from the dead. Now people might die for what they believe to be true, even if they are wrong. But few will die for a known lie or deception. The fact that the disciples died saying that Jesus was alive, and therefore Lord and God, means that they certainly did not have his dead body hidden away somewhere obscure.

4. That Jesus was not actually dead when buried and left the tomb on his own. 

If no one stole the body, then perhaps Jesus did not quite die on the cross, but was buried alive and revived in the tomb. 

This may be. However, this position reduces to absurdity when we are asked to believe that, half dead due to blood loss, a beating and no medical attention after his crucifixion, Jesus struggled free from his shroud, pushed aside a stone that three healthy women were not sure they could move (see Mark 16:3), and walked several miles on wounded feet. Then he met his disciples, claimed to be risen, victorious over the power of death, and was so convincing that Thomas called him “My Lord and my God” (John 20:28). After about a month he wandered off and died in solitude.

Remember that no one ever found his body, and that there was massive motivation to search for it. This is surely a theory of desperate last resort. A supernatural resurrection is certainly not less probable than this, unless we reject it from the outset by an uncontrollable bias. Perhaps we should rethink our position as skeptical lawyer Frank Morrison was forced to do by the evidence (Who Moved the Stone).

In Conclusion

In conclusion, there is considerable weight behind the claim that Jesus rose from the dead. The implications are staggering! It changes everything. We must then ask why it happened. And we must deal with the Christian claim that this is the supreme act of God intervening in history to restore the world to himself through the life, death and resurrection of Jesus of Nazareth, called the Christ or Messiah.

Hear the profound implications from a modern author Andy Crouch (Culture Making):

The resurrection of Jesus is like a cultural earthquake, its epicenter located in Jerusalem in the early 30s, whose aftershocks are still being felt in the cultural practices of people all over the world, many who have never heard of, and many more who have never believed in, its origins…. The resurrection is the hinge of history—still after two thousand years as far-reaching in its effects as anything that has come since…. The second Adam’s influence on culture comes through the greatest act of dependence, the fulfillment of Israel’s calling to demonstrate faith in the face of the great powers that threatened its existence comes in the willing submission of Jesus to a Roman cross, broken by, but breaking forever its power…. Indeed one of the most dramatic cultural effects of the resurrection is the transformation of that heinous cultural artifact known as a cross. An instrument of domination and condemnation becomes a symbol of the kingdom that Jesus proclaimed: an alternative culture where grace and forgiveness are the last word…. He faces the worst that human powers can do and rises, not just with some merely “spiritual” triumph over those powers, but with a cultural triumph—an answer, right in the midst of human history, to all the fears of Israel in the face of its enemies…. The worst that culture can do, is transformed into a sign of the kingdom of God–the realm of forgiveness, mercy, love and indestructible life.

Other Resources:

N.T. Wright’s excellent DVD video on the Resurrection; and his book The Resurrection of the Son of God: Christian Origins and the Question of God, Volume 3. (academic depth)

Richard Swinburne, The Resurrection of God Incarnate.  Oxford: Clarendon Press, 2003.

Classic Historic Debate between Gary Habermas and Antony Flew: Did jesus Rise from the Dead? The Resurrection Debate. Harper & Row, 1987.  (republished Wipf & Stock 2003) Famous Atheist Philosopher Antony Flew has converted to theism since then. See Antony Flew, There is a god.

The Case for the Resurrection of Jesus Gary Habermas and Michael Licona

The Resurrection Argument That Changed a Generation of Scholars - Gary Habermas at UCSB

Eugene Peterson, Practice Resurrection.

Michael Green, Christ is Risen: So what? (popular writing)

Resurrection Reflections: William Lane Craig in Southampton, UK

Tim Keller Encountering the Risen King

An Easter Carol by Christina Georgina Rossetti

Spring bursts to-day,
For Christ is risen and all the earth’s at play.

Flash forth, thou Sun,
The rain is over and gone, its work is done.

Winter is past,
Sweet Spring is come at last, is come at last.

Bud, Fig and Vine,
Bud, Olive, fat with fruit and oil and wine.

Break forth this morn
In roses, thou but yesterday a Thorn.

Uplift thy head,
O pure white Lily through the Winter dead.

Beside your dams
Leap and rejoice, you merry-making Lambs.

All Herds and Flocks
Rejoice, all Beasts of thickets and of rocks.

Sing, Creatures, sing,
Angels and Men and Birds and everything.

All notes of Doves
Fill all our world: this is the time of loves.


This article has been republished with permission. You can find the original article here: Is there Rational Evidence for the Resurrection?


Dr. Gordon E. Carkner, the Director of Graduate & Faculty Campus Ministries, along with his wife Ute love connecting with future global leaders within the graduate student university community. Through hospitality, biblical investigation, prayer and discussions of faith and academic studies, these students are drawn into kingdom concerns and introduced to God's powerful agape love. 


print



Science & Scientism Science & Scientism

Dr. Ard Louis, Professor of Theoretical Physics at the University of Oxford, speaks on "Science and...
Read More..

Re-thinking our Myth of the Secular Re-thinking our Myth of the Secular

Many people seem to be hungry for fresh perspectives on the current Western cultural ethos. Dr. Gor...
Read More..

Transcendent Goodness & Human Hospitality  Transcendent Goodness & Human Hospitality 

What are the theological and philosophical roots or  drivers  of hospitality? From his research on ...
Read More..

The Perils of Radical Individualism The Perils of Radical Individualism

In this webinar, Dr. Gordon Carkner analyses what is at stake in a radical individualist stance. He...
Read More..

The Genius of Truth The Genius of Truth

Dr. Gordon E. Carkner, a Meta-Educator with postgraduate students at UBC Vancouver, examines some o...
Read More..

Incarnational Spirituality Series: A New Horizon Incarnational Spirituality Series: A New Horizon

Incarnational Spirituality Series: A New Horizon. Read part one, and find links to the rest of this...
Read More..

Freedom, Identity and the Good: the Theological Ethics of Christian Community Freedom, Identity and the Good: the Theological Ethics of Christian Community

Christian freedom flourishes within a trinitarian horizon. Trinitarian divine goodness proves to be...
Read More..

The Big Question: Why Do We Suffer? The Big Question: Why Do We Suffer?

Dr. Gordon E. Carkner leads an inspiring discussion on this key universal question. He claims that ...
Read More..

Charles Taylor and the Modern Search for Identity Charles Taylor and the Modern Search for Identity

In the modern quest for identity, there is no better place to turn than premiere Canadian philosoph...
Read More..

The Existential Identity Crisis of Millennials The Existential Identity Crisis of Millennials

Dr. Gordon E. Carkner opens this sensitive discussion of Millennial angst from a compassionate stan...
Read More..

Protecting Democracy from the Outside Protecting Democracy from the Outside

John Owen Lecture. Wednesday November 18, 2020 put on by the UBC Graduate & Faculty Christian Forum...
Read More..

Gnosticism vs. the Gospel of Incarnation Gnosticism vs. the Gospel of Incarnation

Gnosticism, both historically and presently, offers a starkly alternative religion to Christianity ...
Read More..

Sy Garte - UBC GFCF Lecture Sy Garte - UBC GFCF Lecture

For the benefit of you and your friends and family, here is the Sy Garte lecture from Thursday, Oct...
Read More..

Voices Around the World Voices Around the World

Gordon & Ute Carkner share snippets from letters they've received from past alumni at UBC.
Read More..

Reflections on UBC Comagape Conference Reflections on UBC Comagape Conference

Conversations with a Jewish Professor & UBC Students. These are Gord Carkner's reflections on the r...
Read More..

 Charles Taylor and the Modern Quest for Identity Charles Taylor and the Modern Quest for Identity

Pre-eminent McGill University Emeritus Philosopher Charles Taylor is an iconic international schola...
Read More..

Everything is New in 2020 in Light of the Incarnation Everything is New in 2020 in Light of the Incarnation

God’s word of love becomes flesh in us, is embodied in us, is enacted through us and in doing so, t...
Read More..

OC Reads: One Thousand Gifts OC Reads: One Thousand Gifts

OC Reads: Book Recommendations from OC Team Members. Read Gord Carkner's recommendation for An...
Read More..

The Prayer of a Student Skeptic The Prayer of a Student Skeptic

Dear God, Buddha, Allah, Plato, Krishna, Beings from other planets, Jesus, Confucius, Zeus, Ra, the...
Read More..

The Great Escape from Nihilism The Great Escape from Nihilism

This book is about a journey: out of the confines of nihilism into the heart of meaning. It presses...
Read More..

Campus Ministry Campus Ministry

Sparking lively dialogue about the powerful implications of the Christian faith for academic work ...
Read More..

Dialogue on Jesus Dialogue on Jesus

There exist today in the minds of people many different versions of Jesus. Cultural interpretation ...
Read More..

...

Rescuing the Lost Language of Meaning
Some elements in modern culture have worked to repress/restrict our language usage--in particular what Charles Taylor calls the 'meta-biological', the language of significance. Restricted language means necessarily limi...
Read more...
Sent & Sending: Gord & Ute Carkner
A closer look at Gord & Ute's campus ministry at UBC. 
Read more...
Is there Rational Evidence for the Resurrection?
Some allege that the resurrection of Jesus was a hoax. We must decide whether there is a more plausible alternative than an actual physical, bodily resurrection. Much hangs on the answer.
Read more...
Science & Scientism
Dr. Ard Louis, Professor of Theoretical Physics at the University of Oxford, speaks on "Science and Scientism" in this online webinar. Dr. Paul Rowe, from Trinity Western University, speaks on "The Appeal of Caesar: the...
Read more...
Re-thinking our Myth of the Secular
Many people seem to be hungry for fresh perspectives on the current Western cultural ethos. Dr. Gordon E. Carkner argues that we need to urgently rethink our view of the 'secular'. In this video, he reveals somethi...
Read more...
Transcendent Goodness & Human Hospitality 
What are the theological and philosophical roots or  drivers  of hospitality? From his research on the self in late modernity, Dr. Carkner delves into this question.
Read more...
 

 

2 - 7201 72 Street Delta BC V4G 1M5